Department of Energy and Climate Change

Severn Tidal Power

Skip to content| Accessibility

Severn Tidal Power

Feasibility Study Conclusions 

The Government has concluded that it does not see a strategic case for public investment in a tidal energy scheme in the Severn estuary at this time, but wishes to keep the option open for future consideration. The decision follows consideration by Ministers of the evidence gathered during a 2 year feasibility study to assess whether, and on what terms, Government could support a tidal energy scheme in the Severn estuary.

The decision has been taken in the context of wider climate and energy goals, including consideration of the relative costs, benefits and impacts of a Severn tidal power scheme, as compared to other options for generating low carbon electricity. The outcome of the feasibility study does not preclude a privately financed scheme coming forward in the meantime, and Government is talking to private sector consortia and individual companies about their ideas, and discussing with the Commission how to comply with European environmental legislation.

The decision not to rule out a scheme in the longer term recognises the significant UK resource that the Severn estuary presents. The huge 14-metre tidal range of the Severn estuary - one of the highest in the world - represents a renewable, predictable resource with the potential (through a tidal power scheme) to generate up to 5 percent of the UK’s electricity needs, and so potentially make an important contribution to the UK’s renewable energy targets and wider climate change and energy goals in the future.

The feasibility study report, which summarises the study conclusions, can be downloaded from the links below, together with the main supporting documents.

The Government received a total of 35 responses to the publication of the conclusions and the supporting reports, which can be summarised as follows:

  • The early responses were mostly short emails from engineers and others who were critical of the decision not to go ahead with a large Severn barrage, though there were a couple who agreed with the decision and complimented the study team on its transparent and inclusive approach.
  • There were half a dozen substantive responses from serious organisations, i.e. the Environment Agency, Countryside Council for Wales, RSPB, WWF, Bristol Port Company and Parsons Brinckerhoff, plus a couple of fairly detailed responses from individual engineers. The EA, CCW and WWF said that work should start now to address the significant uncertainties and data gaps, e.g. flood risk management and modelling of far-field effects; detailed baseline monitoring of distribution of species and habitats; study of fish behaviour and movement in the estuary; and assessment of measures to prevent and reduce possible impacts. CCW, WWF, RSPB and PB all called for Government to provide further support for innovative and environmentally benign technologies.
  • The Government welcomes these responses and will keep them on record, but it does not see a case to change the decision announced in October.

Full list of reports:

  1. Feasibility Study Conclusions and Summary Report (PDF, 2994Kb)
  2. SEA Environmental Report (PDF, 2328Kb)
  3. Options Definition Report  Volume 1 (PDF, 2435Kb)
  4. Options Definition Report  Volume 2, Appendices
  5. Options Definition Report  Volume 3, Drawings
  6. Impact Assessment (PDF, 953Kb)
  7. Regional Economic Impacts Study (PDF, 212Kb)
  8. Commercial Assessment Part 1 (PDF, 807Kb)
  9. Commercial Assessment Part 2: Legal Review (PDF, 204Kb)
  10.  Economic valuation of the effect of the shortlisted tidal options on the ecosystem services of the Severn Estuary - summary report (PDF, 380Kb)
  11.  Economic Valuation of the effect of the shortlisted tidal options on the ecosystem services of the Severn Estuary - final technical report (1,579Kb)
  12.  Report to Inform a Stage 1 (Screening) Habitats Regulations Assessment – Non-Technical Summary (PDF,  89Kb)
  13.  Report to Inform Stage 2 (Appropriate Assessment) Habitats Regulations Assessment  – Non-Technical Summary (PDF, 526Kb) 
  14.  Compensatory Measures – Potential Investigation into Equal Value (PDF, 188Kb)
  15.  Potential for compensatory measures report (PDF, 762Kb) 


    a. Annex A: Criteria for inclusion or conditional inclusion of habitats directive compensatory measures (PDF, 36Kb)
    b. Annex B: New site designation as a compensatory measure under Article 6 (PDF, 45Kb)
    c. Annex C: Compensatory measures - application of compensation ratios under Article 6 (4) (PDF, 135Kb)

  16. A strategic level review of the issues surrounding potential habitat creation mitigation / compensation measures for SPA waterbirds affected by tidal power development on the Severn Estuary (PDF, 929Kb)
  17. Feasibility of large scale managed realignment (PDF, 526Kb)
  18.  Grid study non-technical summary (PDF, 490Kb)
  19.  Grid study technical report (PDF, 7,571Kb)
  20.  Supply chain survey report (PDF, 6,763Kb)
     

    Severn Embryonic Technologies Scheme (SETS) reports
     

  21.  Rolls Royce Atkins Report (including Route Map) (PDF, 6614Kb)
  22.  VerdErg Report (PDF, 2886Kb)
  23.  VerdErg - Development Road Map Report (PDF, 4183Kb)
  24.  Severn Tidal Fence Consortium Report (PDF, 925Kb)
  25.  Severn Tidal Fence Consortium Development Route Map (PDF,  68Kb)
     

    Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Theme Reports
     

  26.  Air & climatic factors and resources & waste effects and interrelationships (PDF, 720Kb)
  27.  Biodiversity effects and interrelationships (PDF, 467Kb)
  28.  Historic environment and landscape & seascape effects and interrelationships (PDF, 1,275Kb) 
  29.  Physicochemical effects and interrelationships (PDF, 1,708Kb) 
  30.  Society & economy effects & interrelationships (PDF, 669Kb)
     

    Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Topic Reports (grouped by theme)

    (7 available via weblink as full versions, 9 available via weblink as Non-Technical Summaries (NTS).

  31.  Air & climatic factors - air quality and carbon footprint (PDF, 2,441Kb) 
  32.  Resources and waste (PDF, 858Kb) 
  33.  Marine ecology
  34.  Migratory and estuarine fish (PDF, 1,305Kb) 
  35.  Terrestrial and freshwater ecology (PDF, 100Kb)
  36.  Waterbirds (PDF, 212Kb)
  37.  Historic environment (NTS) (PDF, 117Kb) 
  38.  Landscape and seascape (NTS)  (PDF, 198Kb) 
  39.  Hydraulics and geomorphology (NTS) (PDF, 154Kb) 
  40.  Marine water quality (NTS) (PDF, 255Kb) 
  41.  Flood risk and land drainage (NTS) (PDF, 164Kb) 
  42.  Freshwater environment and associated interfaces (PDF, 1,283Kb) 
  43.  Communities (NTS) (PDF, 153Kb) 
  44.  Navigation (NTS) (PDF, 119Kb) 
  45.  Noise & vibration (PDF, 499Kb)
  46.  Other sea uses (NTS) (PDF, 127Kb)
Link to home page