Privy Council Office
Home Contacts Feedback Sitemap Links Freedom of Information Text only Search
Judgments
 

Index of 2003 Judgments

Notes: (1) Judgments in devolution cases are separately listed at the end of this index.
          (2) Italics indicate that the judgment is an Advance copy, still subject to minor amendments.
          (3) As from 2001, Privy Council judgments bear the neutral citation:- [Year] UKPC [no.]

No. Case names Origin Date of judgment
1. (1) Bertrand Roberts and (2) Roland Roberts v. The State (Appeal No. 12 of 2002) Trinidad and Tobago 15th January 2003
2. (1) Caricom Cinemas Limited (2) Trinidad Cinemas Limited and (3) Michael Leschaloupe v. Republic Bank Limited (Appeal No. 42 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 15th January 2003
3.

Maurice John Kirk v. The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons (Appeal No. 51 of 2002)      Oral Judgment upon an Interlocutory Petition by the Appellant

The Disciplinary Committee of the RCVS 14th January 2003
4. Sang Fat Company Limited v. Rajlal (Appeal No. 87 of 2001) Mauritius 21st January 2003
5. Dr. Naveed Hasan v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 52 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 21st January 2003
6. The Director of Public Prosecutions v. Kurt Mollison (No. 2) (Appeal No. 88 of 2001) Jamaica 22nd January 2003
7.

Dr. Surendra Charan Misra v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 43 of 2002)

The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 22nd January 2003
8.

Dr. Hossain Aaalamani v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 74 of 2002)                        

Oral Judgment upon a petition to dismiss for non-prosecution

 

The Committee on Professional Performance of The GMC 22nd January 2003
9. Michael Pringle v. The Queen (Appeal No. 17 of 2002) Jamaica 27th January 2003
10. (1) Ian Brown and (2) Everitt Isaac v. The State (Appeal No. 9 of 2002) Trinidad and Tobago 29th January 2003
11. Associated Electric & Gas Insurance Services Limited v. European Reinsurance Company of Zurich (Appeal No. 93 of 2001) Bermuda 29th January 2003
12.

(1) Joyce Chaitlal and Ganga Persad Chaitlal (in substitution for Kanhai Mahase, deceased) (2) Dhanierami Jaglal and (3) Maharani Jaglal v. Chanderlal Ramlal  (Appeal No. 36 of 2001)

Trinidad and Tobago 5th February 2003
13. (1) Donovan Crawford (2) Regardless Limited & (3) Alma Crawford v. Financial Institutions Services Limited Judgment upon a Petition for Special Leave to Appeal Jamaica 6th February 2003
14. Eustace Potter v. Port Services Limited (Appeal No. 48 of 2001) Antigua and Barbuda 6th February 2003
15. Dr. Usha S. N. Singh v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 53 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

21st January 2003 

Reasons for Report 17th February 2003

16. Dr. Rajnikant Kantilal Patel v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 48 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

27th January 2003

Reasons for Report 17th February 2003

17. (1) Martha Perch (2) Ingrid Dennie and (3) Jennifer Commissiong v. The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago (Appeal No. 57 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 20th February 2003
18. Dr. Peter Henry Gauvain Sandon v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 47 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

27th January 2003

Reasons for Report 27th February 2003

19. (1) Opua Ferries Limited and (2) Commerce Commission v. Fullers Bay of Islands Limited (Appeal No. 79 of 2001) New Zealand 5th March 2003
20. Corozal Free Zone Development Ltd v. Flynagen Ltd (Appeal No. 96 of 2001) Belize 10th March 2003
21. The Royal Bank of Trinidad and Tobago v. (1) Bobby Vashista Persad and (2) Dipchand Lakhan (Appeal No. 62 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 17th March 2003
22. "R" v. Her Majesty's Attorney-General for England and Wales (Appeal No. 61 of 2002)  New Zealand 17th March 2003
23. Parry Husbands v. Warefact Limited (Appeal No. 74 of 2001) St. Lucia 19th March 2003
24. Dr. Adil Mahmud Raji v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 75 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 19th March 2003
25. (1) William Alexander McLennan and (2) Wilson I McLennan and Others v. The Attorney General (Appeal No. 97 of 2001) New Zealand 19th March 2003
26. Vadim Schmidt v. Rosewood Trust Limited (Appeal No. 2 of 2002)  Isle of Man 27th March 2003
27

(1) Alexander Benedetto v. The Queen and (2) William Labrador v. The Queen    

(Appeal Nos 62 and 88 of 2002) 

British Virgin Islands 7th April 2003
28 Kevin Francis Gangar v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 15 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

8th January 2003

Reasons for Report 8th  April 2003

29 Martin Rago v. Indra Ragoonath (Appeal No. 58 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 10th April 2003
30 Mohammed Al-Fallouji v. The General Medical Council  (Appeal No. 87 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 10th April 2003
31

Dr. Pratap Gosai v. The General Medical Council  (Appeal No. 20 of 2002)

The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

21st January 2003

Reasons for Report 10th April 2003

32. Vela Fishing Limited v. The Commissioner of Inland Revenue (Appeal No. 36 of 2002) New Zealand 14th April 2003
33. Dr. Michael Ellman Silver v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 66 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 14th April 2003
34. Alan Roderick Tait v. The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons (Appeal No. 34 of 2002) The Disciplinary Committee of the RCVS

20th March 2003

Reasons for Report 15th April 2003

35.

Liubov Ford v. The Queen (Judgment upon a Petition for Special Leave to Appeal)

 

Gibraltar 9th April 2003
36. Birmal Roy Paria v. The State (Appeal No. 42 of 2002) Trinidad and Tobago 15th April 2003
37. (1) Ian Wight (2) Michael Pilling (3) Michael W. Mackey v. Eckhardt Marine GmbH (Appeal No. 13 of 2002)  Cayman Islands 14th May 2003
38. (1) B and Others (2) Russell McVeagh McKenzie Bartleet & Co. v. (1) Auckland District Law Society (2) Gary J. Judd (Appeal No. 34 of 2002) New Zealand 19th May 2003
39. Roy Green v. Vivia Green (Appeal No. 4 of 2002) Jamaica 20th May 2003
40. Aurelio Pop v. The Queen (Appeal No. 31 of 2002) Belize 22nd May 2003
41. Liubov Ford v. Richard Labrador (Judgment upon a Petition for Special Leave to Appeal) Gibraltar 22nd May 2003
42. Dr. Malcolm Euan Carruthers v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 58 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 3rd June 2003
43. Ramnath Jeetah v. Beejwantee Ramkurrun (Appeal No. 54 of 2001) Mauritius 11th June 2003
44 Dr. Enrique Mateu-Lopez v. The General Medical Council  (Appeal No. 96 of 2002)   The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 16th June 2003
45. Channel Islands Knitwear Company Limited v. Iona Nicola Mackay Hotchkiss (Appeal No. 45 of 2002) Jersey 16th June 2003
46. Carlton Greer v. Alstons Engineering Sales and Services Limited (Appeal No. 61 of 2001) Trinidad and Tobago 19th June 2003
47.

Maurice John Kirk v. The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons (Oral Judgment upon an Interlocutory Petition)

The Disciplinary Committee of the RCVS 17th June 2003 
48. Robert Edward Jones v. Her Majesty's Attorney-General sued on behalf of New Zealand Police (Appeal No. 29 of 2002) New Zealand 19th June 2003
49. (1) Donovan Crawford (2) Regardless Limited (3) Alma Crawford v. Financial  Institutions Services Limited (Judgment upon a petition for Special Leave) Jamaica 19th June 2003
50. (1) Waikato Regional Airport Limited (2) South Pacific Air Charters Limited (3) Palmerston North Airport Limited v. The Attorney General (on behalf of the Director General of Agriculture and Forestry (Appeal No. 77 of 2002) New Zealand 30th June 2003
51. National Commercial Bank (Jamaica) Limited v. (1) Raymond Hew and Clifton Hew (as executors of the estate of Stephen Hew (deceased)) and (2) Raymond Hew (Appeal No. 65 of 2002)  Jamaica 30th June 2003
52. Dr. Arijit Bose v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 6 of 2003) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 30th June 2003
53. (1) Mount Murray Country Club Limited (2) Conrad Hotels Limited and (3) Mount Murray Homes Limited v. (1)(a) Nigel Macleod (b) Mark Solly (c) Martin Bradshaw (The Chairman and Members of the Commission of Inquiry into Mount Murray) and (2) Ian. Q Kelly (The Assessor of Income Tax) (Appeal No. 14 of 2003) The Isle of Man

7th May 2003

Reasons for Report 7th July 2003

54. Newport Farm Limited and 22 others v. Damesh Holdings Limited and Others (Appeal No. 40 of 2002) New Zealand 7th July 2003
55. (1) The Gleaner Company Limited and (2) Dudley Stokes v. Eric Anthony Abrahams (Appeal No. 86 of 2001)  Jamaica 14th July 2003
56. Dr. Saghir A. Qureshi v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 54 of 2002) The Committee on Professional Performance of the GMC

8th May 2003

Reasons for report 14th July 2003

57. Dr. Anna-Marie Brocklebank v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 20 of 2003) The Health Committee of the GMC  14th July 2003
58. Bank of New Zealand v. Board of Management of The Bank of New Zealand Officers' Provident Association (Appeal No. 73 of 2002)  New Zealand 14th July 2003
59. Anthony Peter Sadler v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 59 of 2002) The Committee on Professional Performance of the GMC 15th July 2003
60. Mr Michael Robert Pembrey v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 97 of 2002) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 15th July 2003
61. "B" and others v. The Attorney General and Others (Appeal No. 1 of 2003) New Zealand 16th July 2003
62. (1) Premium Investments Limited (2) Town and Country Resorts Limited v. The Commissioner of General Consumption Tax (Appeal No. 44 of 2002) Jamaica 30th July 2003
63. The Belize Alliance of Conservation Non-Governmental Organisations v. (1) The Department of the Environment (2) Belize Electricity Company Limited (Judgment Upon a Petition for a Conservatory Order) Belize 13th August 2003
64. Antigua Public Utilities Authority v. Malcolm Alphonso Edwards (Appeal No. 35 of 2002) Antigua and Barbuda 2nd October 2003
65. Franklyn Dailey v. Harriet Dailey (Appeal No. 45 of 2002) British Virgin Islands 2nd October 2003
66. Dr. Chaman Lal Anand v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 11 of 2003) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

3rd October 2003

Reasons for Report 24th July 2003

67. Dr. Parviz Seyedi v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 15 of 2003) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

3rd October 2003

Reasons for Report 24th July 2003

68. Bike World Limited v. (1) The Comptroller of Customs (2) The State of Mauritius (Appeal No. 46 of 2002) Mauritius 6th October 2003
69. (1) Andrew Hunter (2) Marlon Moodie v. The Queen (Appeal No. 64 of 2002) Jamaica

8th October 2003

Reasons for Report      9th July 2003

70. (1) Alexander Benedetto v. The Queen (No. 2) and (2) William Labrador v. The Queen (No. 2) (Appeal Nos. 62 and 88. of 2002) British Virgin Islands 20th October 2003
71. Dr. Idowu David Otote v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 22 of 2003) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 21st October 2003
72. Susan Collier v. The Council for Professions Supplementary to Medicine (The Paramedics Board) (Appeal No. 33 of 2003) The Disciplinary Committee of the HPC

7th October 2003

Reasons for Report 29th October 2003

73. Dr. Bibhuti Bhusan Malkhandi v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 29 of 2003) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

6th October 2003

Reasons for Report 29th October 2003

74. Dr. Michael Denis Ignacius Donnelly v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 17 of 2003) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC

2nd October 2003

Reasons for Report 3rd November 2003

75. Dr. Dhirendra Nath Das v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 25 of 2003) The Committee on Professional Performance of the GMC 6th November 2003
76.

Pilar Aida Rojas v. Brian Berllaque

Her Majesty's Attorney General for Gibraltar (Intervener) (Appeal No. 100 of 2002)

Gibraltar 10th November 2003
77. Mukta Gokaldas Hindocha (widow of C.S. Gheewala) and Others v. Mahesh Shamjibhal Juthabhai Gheewala and Others (Appeal No.27 of 2002) Jersey 20th November 2003
78. Balkissoon Roodal v. The State(Appeal No. 18 of 2003) Trinidad and Tobago 20th November 2003
79. Haroon Khan v. The State (Appeal No. 28 of 2003) Trinidad and Tobago 20th November 2003
80. (1) Dr. Osama Hassan Salha and (2) Mr. Naim Abusheikha v. The General Medical Council (Appeal Nos. 32 and 35 of 2003) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 24th November 2003
81. Leta Almeda v. Her Majesty's Attorney General for Gibraltar (Appeal No. 57 of 2002) Gibraltar 24th November 2003
82. Marcelle Skeete v. The State (Appeal No. 89 of 2002) Trinidad and Tobago 24th November 2003
83. Pratt Contractors Limited v. Transit New Zealand (Appeal No. 84 of 2002) New Zealand 1st December 2003
84. Myra Wills v. Elma Roselina Wills (Appeal No. 50 of 2002) Jamaica 1st December 2003
85. Trinidad Home Developers Limited (in voluntary liquidation) v. IMH Investments Limited (Appeal No. 49 of 2002)  Trinidad and Tobago 8th December 2003
86. (1) Donald Panton (2) Janet Panton (3) Edwin Douglas v. Financial Institutions Services Limited (Appeal No. 95 of 2002) Jamaica 15th December 2003
87. Dr. Ravi Kant Agarwal v. The General Medical Council (Appeal No. 16 of 2003) The Professional Conduct Committee of the GMC 18th December 2003

Judgments in Devolution Cases

No. Case names Origin Date of Judgment
D1 Hellen Clark (Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy) v. Christopher John Kelly (DRA. No. 2 of 2002) The High Court of Justiciary 11th February 2003

Note: Italics indicate that the judgment is an Advance copy, still subject to minor amendments.

Print
Related Issues
 Judgments
 In this Section
Judicial Committee
Judgments
Appeal Statistics