Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution

Background to the Marine Fisheries Study
Scoping the Study
Announcement of the Study and invitation for comments on the scope by 11 September 2002
Fisheries seminar
Seminar in November 2002 to help define the scope of the Study
Invitation to submit evidence
Letter of February 2003 inviting submissions of evidence by 30 May 2003
Studies commissioned as part of report
Publication timetable

Background to the Marine Fisheries Study

In June 2002, the Royal Commission announced its new study into the environmental effects of marine fisheries, the serious concerns that they raise and how these might best be addressed. The study commenced in February 2003.

Fisheries are, in the view of many, one of the major causes of damage to the marine environment but the extent, and even the existence, of such damage is disputed. This is an opportune time to consider the wide environmental consequences of fisheries. We are moving from the hunter-gatherer stage of exploiting the ocean's resources towards farming the oceans. Arguably we are at much the same point with fisheries as we were with agriculture after the second world war. Technological advances and economic pressures are leading to an intensification, which has the potential to wreak as much damage on the oceans as intensive agriculture has on land over recent decades. With agriculture we asked the wrong question - how to maximise the production of food, instead of looking at the wider functions of the rural environment, with their rich inter-dependencies. We must try to ensure that the problems that could arise with intensive fisheries are foreseen, so that they can be avoided.

The Commission's study of the environmental effects of marine fisheries is being conducted in two stages: first to scope the topics to be included in the Study and second to seek evidence and reach conclusions. The scoping stage commenced in June 2002; the request for evidence was issued in February 2003.

Scoping the Study

The announcement of the study explained the background, indicated the broad topics that the Commission proposed to consider, and invited views. In addition to being posted on the website, the letter inviting the submission of information for the scoping phase of the study was sent to over one hundred organisations in June 2002. Details of the study were also publicised in a news release.

Some thirty responses were received and these inputs helped the Commission in drawing up its programme for a seminar, at which the issues could be explored in more detail.

Fisheries seminar

On 4 November 2002, the Commission hosted a seminar at the University of Edinburgh to discuss wide ranging issues relevant to deciding the scope of the Fisheries Study. Speakers from a variety of backgrounds addressed such topics as: how firm is the evidence of environmental damage; is it worsening; what should be the aims of marine environmental policy; and can European waters be considered in isolation.

The lively discussion gave valuable guidance to the Commission, and pointed to a study organised on a few inter-connected lines:

• identifying key scientific considerations and approaches
• developing effective regulatory and management practices
• having institutional arrangements which genuinely involve the relevant parties, recognise their aspirations and ensure that the environment is safeguarded.

The report of the seminar is available in pdf format (16pp, 176Kb).

Invitation to submit evidence

The central aim of the Marine Fisheries Study is to seek a coherent framework within which fisheries practice can be consistent with rich and diverse marine ecosystems and with protection and appropriate enhancement of other aspects of the marine environment. All forms of fisheries will be covered, including industrial, other capture, aquaculture and fish ranching. The wider economic and social consequences of fisheries practice will be taken into account. In particular, the Commission will be looking at:

• Marine science and data, in relation to the issues covered by the study
• Regulatory or management practices and regimes
• The institutional/ legal framework.

The invitation to submit evidence listed a series of issues that the Commission intends to address. These statements and questions are not intended to limit the range of study, but rather focus attention on the areas where Members believe they are most in need of input at this stage.

The invitation letter was sent to over one hundred and twenty organisations in February 2003. The Commission would also welcome evidence from any other interested organisation or individual. The deadline for submitting evidence was 30 May 2003.

Some twenty-five responses were received and these inputs have helped the Commission in deciding which issues would be explored in more detail in the report. In addition, the Commission received oral evidence from a number of organisations and consulted with a number of of individuals. During the course of the study, Members of the Commission and its Secretariat made a series of visits to relevant organisations and countries, including:

Members of the Commission arriving on board a trawler

September 2003 – Scotland, visit to a fish farm facility in Stirling. 9 September 2002 – Suffolk, visit to CEFAS Lowestoft laboratory and excursion on the research vessel, Endeavour. End January 2003 – New Zealand, Discussions with New Zealand Ministry of Fisheries and Department of Conservation. September 2003 – Japan November 2003 – Norway, Discussions with the Norwegian Ministry of Fisheries; Bellona; Stolt SeaFarms; Institute of Marine Research, Bergen; Institute of Aquaculture, Bergen; and the National Institute of Nutrition and Seafood Research. 15-17 November 2003 – US Conference at Scripps Institute of Oceanography, California and discussions with Daniel Pauly and Jeremy Jackson 16 January 2004 – Scotland, Visit to Biomar (UK) Ltd aquaculture feed production plant at Grangemouth. 5-6 March 2004 – Lancashire and Irish Sea, visit to Fleetwood fish processing company in Morecambe Bay and excursion onboard the trawler Jacinta in the Irish Sea with representatives of the NFFO and the North West Sea Fisheries Committee. March 2004 – Brussels - Discussions with DG Fisheries and the Institute of European Environmental Policy. 22-26 May 2004 – US, discussions with representatives of NOAA’s National Marine Fisheries Service (including its Northeast Fisheries Science Center), NOAA’s Chesapeake Bay Office, NOAA’s National Ocean Service (N/IP), Pew Oceans Commission, National Fisheries Institute, The Ocean Conservancy, Oceana, the US Ocean Policy Commission, the US State Department and Marine Fish Conservation Network. August 2004 – Australia, discussions with staff working at the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park.

Studies commissioned for report

The following papers were commissioned in the course of the study:
A study on the consequences of technological innovation in the capture fishing industry and the likely effects upon environmental impacts – A. Revill, CEFAS. September 2003.
The potential impact of technological innovation on the aquaculture industry – Institute ofAquaculture and Department of Marketing, University of Stirling. September 2003
Design of marine protected area networks in the North Sea and Irish Sea. C.M Roberts and Mason, L. In press, 2004.

Publication timetable
The report was published in December 2004.

Top

Back to Current Studies